Subsidence and Home Insurance in the UK: What to Do in the First Week After You Spot Cracks (2026 Guide)

Written by Asim Khan | Founder & Editor of PolicyScopes

 A crack appears over a window frame, and a door that closed fine in June now sticks. There is a good chance you will want to do something straight away: fill the crack, call a builder, or cut down the tree you have always suspected.

Insurers and brokers that wrote about this in 2026 say the same thing again and again: the first week matters, and several of the obvious instincts can cause problems with a claim. This guide goes through the five decisions people face in that week, backed by the latest industry figures.

A few honest notes. This guide is about the UK, and it is general information, not a surveyor's or lawyer's advice. Much of what I read came from insurers, brokers and firms that sell related services, so I lean on the Association of British Insurers (ABI) figures where I can, and I flag where a point comes from a single source. For the basics of how buildings cover works, Home Insurance Explained is the place to start.



A diagonal crack in a brick house wall, representing subsidence and what to do about it for home insurance in the UK



What the 2026 Numbers Say

The ABI reports that its members received a record 13,000 new domestic subsidence claims between July and September 2026, up from 8,000 in the same period a year earlier. The ABI's records on claims notified go back to 1991.

Costs are climbing too. Home insurers paid out £72 million on domestic subsidence claims in the second quarter of 2026, and the average claim reached a record £20,000, more than £2,000 higher than a year earlier. For comparison, the ABI put the average domestic fire claim at £38,000 and the average flood claim at £28,000, so subsidence sits in the same league. Meanwhile, the average annual home insurance premium for the third quarter of 2026 was £329, unchanged from a year earlier, which suggests premiums have not yet reflected the claims surge.

Subsidence is the sinking of the ground under a property. In the UK it is most often linked to clay soil shrinking in dry weather. Trade commentary describes 2026 as combining record low rainfall, very dry soil and sustained high temperatures in areas already prone to clay shrinkage.


Decision One: Is It Subsidence, or Just a Crack?

Not every crack is serious. A council guidance document I read says cracks from ordinary causes are usually uniform and narrow, from hairline up to about 3mm, and that cracks up to roughly 5mm can appear in unusually dry spells. The ABI's own checklist points to these warning signs:

  • cracks wider than about 3mm, roughly the thickness of a £1 coin
  • diagonal cracks, especially if wider at the top than the bottom
  • cracks that appear suddenly rather than gradually
  • cracks visible both inside and outside the home
  • doors and windows that suddenly become difficult to open or close

You cannot diagnose subsidence from a photo, and I am not trying to. The point is to decide whether to call your insurer, and with several of these signs together, the sources say you should.


Decision Two: Who Do I Call, and When?

Call the insurer named on your policy schedule, as soon as reasonably possible. One source points out that claims are handled by the insurer, not the broker, so calling the broker first is a detour. One page says there is no fixed legal deadline to declare subsidence, but still advises telling the insurer as soon as you suspect it.

When you call, photograph the cracks with something for scale and note the date. A short log of dates, names and what was said helps if a claim is disputed. How to Claim Insurance covers how to document a claim and what to do if it is denied.


Decision Three: Should I Fill the Crack or Fix It Myself?

No, according to the sources I read. Brokers advise against filling cracks, removing trees or starting permanent structural repairs before speaking to the insurer. One broker adds that appointing your own surveyor first can leave you paying for it, because costs may not be recoverable if the damage turns out not to come from an insured risk.

The reason is practical: the insurer needs to see what the damage looked like, and may want monitoring over time. Cracks often close up in the wetter winter months and then reopen the next summer, which is why a quick cosmetic fix can hide the evidence without fixing the cause.


Decision Four: What About the Tree?

Trees are often part of the story, because roots draw water from the soil. Insurers may ask for a tree to be removed to stop the problem getting worse, and that request comes through the claims process, with evidence.

Older ABI guidance suggested keeping certain trees well away from buildings, with distances such as about 40m for willows, 35m for poplars and 30m for oaks and elms. Treat that as background, and not as a rule for your garden. The sound advice is the same as above: do not cut it down yourself before speaking to the insurer, because removal can matter to the claim, and the right action depends on the evidence.


Decision Five: I Recently Switched Insurer. Who Handles This?

This is the least known part of the process, and it matters in a year like 2026. The ABI's Domestic Subsidence Claims Agreement sets out which insurer handles a claim notified after you change insurer, depending on timing. From the summaries I read, a claim notified within eight weeks of switching goes to your previous insurer, and one notified more than a year after switching goes to your current insurer. I only saw part of the table, so I am not giving the periods in between. Check the full ABI wording or ask both insurers.

Two related points. You must declare any known or past subsidence when you take out a new policy. And if you have a claim history, a new insurer has no obligation to take you on, though most insurers subscribe to the agreement and specialist insurers exist for properties with a subsidence history.


What the Policy Usually Covers, and the Excess

Most standard UK buildings insurance covers subsidence, though sources say a higher excess, commonly around £1,000, applies to these claims. Two broker sources gave that figure, so treat it as typical and check your own schedule. Insurance Deductibles Explained covers how excess works, including why a large excess changes the sums on a smaller repair.

Policies often cover the building and not the garden wall or driveway in the same way, so check what is excluded. If you let the property, or live in a flat, ask who holds the buildings policy, because your ability to claim depends on that. And if the property is subject to coal-mining subsidence, one source says to claim through the Mining Remediation Authority, not your insurer.


After the Claim: Renewal and Selling

Several sources say your existing insurer will normally continue cover after repairs, sometimes with a higher subsidence excess, and that a subsidence history can raise premiums or the excess. If you later sell, you will usually need to disclose the history, and it can affect buyers and their lenders. A previous subsidence claim does not automatically make a house hard to sell, but it does mean the paperwork matters, so keep the insurer's reports and repair records.

Subsidence is one of several weather-related risks that standard cover treats differently, and Flood Insurance Explained covers another one that home policies commonly exclude.


A Worked Illustration (Invented Numbers)

You find a diagonal crack that has widened over a fortnight. You fill it with filler, then pay a surveyor £600 to inspect it before telling anyone. A month later, the crack has reopened and you finally call your insurer.

If the insurer decides the damage is from an insured cause, the claim may proceed, and the average repair cost in the ABI data is £20,000. With a £1,000 excess, the insurer would pay the rest, up to your limit. But if your own surveyor's fee is treated as an unapproved cost, you may not get the £600 back. And the filler may have made it harder for the insurer to see how the damage developed.

Now compare that with the better sequence: photograph the crack with a scale, call the insurer the same day, and wait for their instructions. The difference is not the building. It is the order of the steps.


Your First-Week Checklist

  1. Photograph every crack with a scale and a date, inside and outside.
  2. Note when you first saw each one and whether it has grown.
  3. Call the insurer named on your policy schedule. Keep a log of the call.
  4. Do not fill cracks, cut trees or start structural repairs before the insurer has seen them.
  5. Check your policy for the subsidence excess.
  6. If you switched insurer recently, tell the new insurer and ask who is handling the claim.
  7. If you rent or live in a flat, tell your landlord or freeholder.
  8. Keep every letter, report and receipt.

Mistakes Worth Naming

Treating a wide diagonal crack as cosmetic. Calling a broker and assuming the claim has been started. Filling cracks before an insurer has seen them. Hiring a surveyor or tree surgeon first. Forgetting the higher excess. Not declaring subsidence history when taking a new policy. And assuming a claim in the first year after switching insurer is automatically handled by the new insurer.


Frequently Asked Questions

Does home insurance cover subsidence? Most standard UK buildings policies do, subject to terms and a higher excess, which sources put at around £1,000.

How wide does a crack need to be to worry? The ABI says to watch for cracks wider than about 3mm and for diagonal cracks that are wider at the top. Several signs together are a reason to call your insurer.

Should I fill the crack first? Sources advise against it. Brokers say not to fill cracks, remove trees or carry out permanent repairs before speaking to the insurer.

I switched insurers recently. Who handles my claim? It depends on how long after switching you report it, under the ABI Domestic Subsidence Claims Agreement. A claim notified within eight weeks goes to your previous insurer, and one notified more than a year later goes to your current insurer.

Will a subsidence claim raise my premium? It can. Sources say your insurer may continue cover after repairs, sometimes with a higher subsidence excess, and that a history can raise premiums.

Can I get cover if my home has had subsidence before? A new insurer need not take you on, but specialist insurers exist and most insurers subscribe to the ABI agreement for the first year after a change of insurer.


One Phone Call Before Any Repair

The simplest summary of everything above is this: take photos, make one call, then wait. Almost every complication I read about came from doing something first, whether that was filling a crack, hiring a surveyor or cutting a tree, and then telling the insurer afterwards.

In a year with record claims, the people whose claims run most smoothly are not those with luck on their side. They are the ones who documented early and let the insurer see the evidence.


Published by PolicyScopes — making insurance and personal finance easier to understand through independent research and reliable sources.

Popular posts from this blog

How Insurance Works: Step-by-Step Guide for Beginners (Complete 2026 Guide)

What Is Insurance? A Complete Beginner’s Guide (2026)

Types of Insurance Explained: A Complete Beginner’s Guide (Life, Health, Auto & More)

How to Claim Insurance: Step-by-Step Guide to Filing Claims Successfully (2026)

Disability Insurance Explained: How It Protects Your Income When You Cannot Work (2026 Guide)

Insurance Deductibles Explained: What They Are and How They Affect Your Claims (2026 Guide)

Best Insurance Plans for Beginners: How to Choose the Right Policy in 2026

Car Insurance Explained: How It Works, What It Covers, and How to Choose the Best Policy (2026 Guide)

Umbrella Insurance Explained: Why Your Existing Coverage Might Not Be Enough (2026 Guide

Types of Life Insurance Explained: Which Policy Is Right for You? (Complete Guide 2026)